No, Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya is not a remake of Just Go With It. In fact, due to their respective release dates, the reverse would be chronologically impossible.
The Bollywood film Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya? was released in 2005, while the Hollywood film Just Go With It premiered six years later in 2011.
Both movies, however, draw their core inspiration from the 1969 American comedy Cactus Flower, which itself was based on a French play. Interestingly, Just Go With It shares a remarkable similarity with Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya in its narrative structure, specific plot twists, and comedic style, leading some to note a potential influence of the earlier Bollywood film on the later Hollywood production.
Shared Inspirations and Narrative Resemblances
Despite their distinct origins and production teams, the two films navigate a similar comedic premise that revolves around a doctor entangled in a web of lies.
- Common Source Material: The fundamental concept for both films stems from Cactus Flower. This original story features a dentist who pretends to be married to avoid commitment, leading to a series of comedic misunderstandings when he falls in love and needs to "divorce" his non-existent wife.
- Parallel Plot Development: Both Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya and Just Go With It elaborate on this premise, featuring a protagonist (a doctor) who invents a fake family scenario (a wife and children) to deter romantic attachments. When a genuine romantic interest emerges, the protagonist enlists the help of an assistant or friend to impersonate the fictional spouse, leading to escalating deception and farcical situations.
- Comedic Elements: The humor in both films often arises from the absurdity of the lies, the awkward interactions between characters, and the eventual unravelling of the deception, all culminating in self-discovery and true love.
Film Overview
To clarify the timeline and common threads, here's a brief comparison:
| Feature | Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya? | Just Go With It |
|---|---|---|
| Release Year | 2005 | 2011 |
| Origin | Bollywood (India) | Hollywood (USA) |
| Key Actors | Salman Khan, Sushmita Sen, Katrina Kaif | Adam Sandler, Jennifer Aniston, Nicole Kidman |
| Primary Source | Inspired by Cactus Flower (1969) | Inspired by Cactus Flower (1969) |
| Genre | Romantic Comedy | Romantic Comedy |
The shared inspiration from Cactus Flower explains the fundamental similarities, while the later release of Just Go With It and its noted resemblance to Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya suggests a possible additional layer of influence in how the classic premise was modernized and presented.
