zaro

Is Only the Lonely a Remake of Marty?

Published in Film Comparisons 2 mins read

No, while Only the Lonely is frequently referred to as an unofficial remake of Marty, it is not a direct or official remake. However, the similarities in their core themes and character dynamics are significant enough to warrant the frequent comparison.

Understanding the Connection

Only the Lonely (1991) and Marty (1955) share a thematic heart, focusing on lonely, middle-aged individuals living with their overbearing mothers and their struggles to find love and independence. This strong parallel leads many to consider Only the Lonely a spiritual successor or an unofficial reinterpretation, rather than a direct adaptation.

Key elements that highlight this thematic connection include:

  • Similar Character Archetypes: In Only the Lonely, the protagonist, Danny Muldoon (played by John Candy), is a Chicago police officer in his thirties. He lives with his sharp-tongued mother, Rose (portrayed by Maureen O'Hara, who came out of a 20-year retirement to make the movie). This setup mirrors the central dynamic of Marty, where the titular character is also an unmarried man in his mid-thirties who lives at home and faces pressure regarding his marital status.
  • Themes of Loneliness and Independence: Both films delve into the challenges faced by their protagonists in breaking free from parental influence and establishing their own lives and romantic relationships. The emotional journeys of Danny and Marty resonate deeply with similar struggles against societal expectations and familial ties.
  • Focus on Everyday Life: Rather than grand narratives, both movies center on the relatable, often poignant, experiences of ordinary people seeking companionship and happiness amidst their daily routines.

While Only the Lonely crafts its own unique narrative with distinct characters and plot developments, the underlying premise of an adult child seeking love while managing a demanding parent is so similar to Marty that it's often considered to be in the "ballpark" of an unofficial remake.