zaro

Why Does a Crushed Bottle Top Sink in Water?

Published in Fluid Dynamics 3 mins read

A crushed bottle top sinks in water because its density becomes greater than the density of water. This is directly in line with the fundamental principle of buoyancy: Objects having more density than water will sink.

When a bottle top, typically made of metal like steel or aluminum, is crushed, its volume significantly decreases while its mass remains the same. Since density is calculated as mass divided by volume (Density = Mass/Volume), reducing the volume without changing the mass leads to an increase in density.

Understanding Density and Buoyancy

Density is a measure of how much "stuff" (mass) is packed into a given space (volume). Water has a density of approximately 1 gram per cubic centimeter (g/cm³).

  • Objects with a density less than water will float. They are lighter for their size than the water they displace.
  • Objects with a density greater than water will sink. They are heavier for their size than the water they displace.

The material a bottle top is made from (e.g., steel or aluminum) is inherently much denser than water.

Material Approximate Density (g/cm³) Buoyancy in Water
Water 1.0 N/A
Steel 7.85 Sinks
Aluminum 2.7 Sinks

The Impact of Crushing

Even an uncrushed bottle top made of metal is likely to sink because its material density is higher than water. However, some objects with high material density can float if their shape traps enough air, effectively increasing their overall volume and thus reducing their average density below that of water. Think of a boat made of steel – it floats because its hollow design displaces a large volume of water.

When a bottle top is crushed:

  1. Volume Reduction: Any air pockets that might have contributed to buoyancy are eliminated or significantly reduced. The bottle top becomes a compact, solid mass.
  2. Increased Average Density: With its volume minimized and mass unchanged, its average density skyrockets, far exceeding the density of water. There's no longer enough displaced water to create an upward buoyant force strong enough to counteract its weight.

Practical Insights

This principle isn't just limited to bottle tops. You can observe it with many common objects:

  • A crumpled piece of aluminum foil vs. a flat sheet: A flat sheet can sometimes float due to its large surface area displacing more water and trapping air, but once crumpled into a compact ball, it sinks immediately.
  • A hollow plastic ball vs. a solid plastic ball of the same material: The hollow ball floats because its overall density (including the air inside) is less than water, while the solid one sinks (if the plastic's density is greater than water).
  • Ships vs. a block of steel: A ship, despite being made of steel, floats because its design displaces an immense volume of water, making its average density (ship + air inside) less than water. A solid block of steel, however, will always sink.

In essence, a crushed bottle top sinks because it's a dense material made even more compact, unequivocally demonstrating the principle that objects having more density than water will sink.