While historical records do not explicitly use the term "crush," evidence strongly suggests a profound and undeniable mutual attraction between Angelica Schuyler Church and Alexander Hamilton, which many contemporaries perceived as romantic. Their relationship went far beyond mere familial ties, marked by deep affection and intellectual camaraderie.
The Potent Connection Between Angelica and Hamilton
Angelica Schuyler Church, the eldest sister of Eliza Schuyler Hamilton, shared a remarkably close and intense bond with her brother-in-law, Alexander Hamilton. Their extensive correspondence, now preserved in institutions like the Library of Congress, reveals the depth of their strong friendship and affection. These letters were not merely polite exchanges but demonstrated a significant emotional connection that was palpable to those around them.
The nature of their relationship was so compelling that it became a subject of observation and speculation even during their lifetimes. As noted by Hamilton biographer Ron Chernow, the attraction between Hamilton and Angelica was so potent and obvious that many people assumed they were lovers. This perception highlights that their bond was not just platonic but carried a significant romantic undertone in the eyes of their peers.
Key Aspects of Their Relationship:
- Deep Emotional Bond: Their letters showcased a profound intellectual and emotional connection, characterized by shared wit, mutual admiration, and genuine concern for each other's well-being.
- Extensive Correspondence: The volume and intimacy of their letters indicate a relationship that was central to both their lives, serving as a significant source of emotional support and intellectual stimulation.
- Public Perception: The fact that many contemporaries believed them to be lovers underscores the intensity and perceived romantic nature of their attraction, moving beyond what might typically be considered a simple crush to something more profound and widely acknowledged.
- Beyond In-Laws: Their connection transcended the conventional boundaries of an in-law relationship, suggesting a unique and deeply personal affinity.
Understanding Their Attraction
The historical context of the late 18th century often saw expressive language in correspondence, but the specific descriptions of Angelica and Alexander's attraction suggest something more than just period-appropriate politeness. The use of terms like "potent" and "obvious" to describe their mutual draw points to an undeniable chemistry that was evident to observers.
| Relationship Aspect | Description Based on Correspondence | Public Perception / Biographer's View |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional Connection | Demonstrated strong friendship and affection | Attraction described as potent and obvious |
| Contemporaries' View | Evident through their shared communications | Many assumed they were romantically involved |
While the precise definition of a "crush" can vary, the historical accounts indicate an attraction that was deeply felt, openly observed, and widely interpreted as romantic, implying a connection far more intense than a casual infatuation. This enduring fascination with their relationship speaks to its unique and compelling nature in American history. For more information on Angelica Schuyler Church, visit her Wikipedia page.
