Yes, a handyman can typically change a toilet.
A handyman is often regarded as a "jack of all trades," possessing a versatile skill set that covers a wide array of household tasks. This broad knowledge base includes common plumbing work, making them well-equipped to handle everyday home repair needs. Many handymen are perfectly capable of tackling plumbing tasks such as replacing a leaky faucet, adjusting the temperature on your water heater, and indeed, replacing your toilet.
Handyman's Expertise in Toilet Replacement
Replacing a toilet is a common home improvement task that falls within the scope of many experienced handymen. This usually involves:
- Disconnecting the old unit: Safely shutting off the water supply, draining the tank and bowl, and detaching the water line and mounting bolts.
- Removing the old toilet: Carefully lifting and removing the old toilet, often disposing of it responsibly.
- Preparing the flange: Cleaning the existing flange and wax ring area to ensure a proper seal for the new toilet.
- Installing the new toilet: Setting the new wax ring, carefully positioning the new toilet, tightening the mounting bolts, and connecting the water supply line.
- Testing and sealing: Checking for leaks and applying caulk around the base for stability and hygiene.
For a standard, like-for-like toilet replacement where no major plumbing alterations or re-piping are required, a handyman is often a cost-effective and efficient choice.
When to Consider a Handyman vs. a Plumber for Toilet Work
While handymen are skilled in many areas, there are specific situations where a licensed plumber might be the more appropriate professional to hire.
| Task Category | Handyman Suited? | Plumber Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Simple Toilet Replacement | Yes (like-for-like swap, no pipe alterations) | No, unless preferred or existing issues |
| Minor Leaks (Toilet Base/Tank) | Yes (often part of replacement or minor repair) | Yes (if leak source is deeper or complex) |
| Clogged Toilet (Minor) | Yes (basic snaking or plunging) | Yes (for persistent, deep clogs or main line issues) |
| New Bathroom Installation | No (involves new pipe routing, code compliance) | Yes (essential for new plumbing lines) |
| Major Pipe Repair/Relocation | No (requires specialized tools, permits, and expertise) | Yes (core expertise for structural plumbing) |
| Drainage System Problems | No (unless very superficial) | Yes (for diagnosing and fixing complex drain issues) |
| Water Pressure Issues | No | Yes (requires system-wide assessment) |
Practical Considerations Before Hiring
Before hiring anyone for plumbing work, even for a seemingly straightforward task like changing a toilet, it's wise to consider:
- Experience Level: Inquire about their specific experience with toilet installations and any potential issues that might arise.
- Insurance: Ensure the professional carries liability insurance to protect both parties in case of accidental damage.
- Local Regulations: While a simple toilet replacement typically doesn't require a permit, always be aware of local building codes, especially if the job involves any alteration to existing plumbing lines.
- Complexity of the Job: If the toilet is difficult to access, the existing flange is damaged, or there are underlying issues with the drainage, a plumber might be better equipped to handle the unforeseen complexities.
In summary, for most standard toilet replacements in a residential setting, a handyman is a perfectly capable and qualified professional to get the job done.
