zaro

Why is Scarlett Johansson not playing Black Widow anymore?

Published in Marvel Cinematic Universe 2 mins read

Scarlett Johansson is no longer playing Black Widow primarily due to her character's on-screen sacrifice in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) and a subsequent contractual dispute concerning the release of her final solo film.

The Character's Narrative Conclusion

Natasha Romanoff, also known as Black Widow, met a definitive end in Avengers: Endgame (2019). Her character heroically sacrificed herself on Vormir to allow the Avengers to acquire the Soul Stone, a pivotal moment in the fight against Thanos. This narrative conclusion meant that, within the main timeline of the MCU, her story arc as Black Widow had come to a close.

Contractual Dispute Over Her Final Film

Despite her character's demise, Johansson reprised the role for the long-awaited prequel film, Black Widow, which was released in 2021. However, the film's release strategy led to a high-profile legal conflict that significantly impacted Johansson's relationship with Disney:

  • Dual Release Strategy: Johansson's contract for Black Widow reportedly stipulated an exclusive theatrical release. However, Disney chose a simultaneous release strategy, making the film available in cinemas and on its streaming service, Disney+, via Premier Access.
  • Impact on Compensation: This hybrid release model directly affected Johansson's earnings. Her compensation package included substantial bonuses tied to the film's box office performance. The argument was that the simultaneous streaming release diverted potential ticket sales from theaters, thereby reducing the box office revenue and, consequently, her valuable box office bonuses.
  • Legal Action and Settlement: Johansson filed a lawsuit against The Walt Disney Company, alleging a breach of contract due to this release decision. The dispute was eventually settled out of court, underscoring the complexities of talent agreements in an evolving distribution landscape that increasingly prioritizes streaming.

The combination of Black Widow's conclusive narrative arc in Avengers: Endgame and the significant contractual disagreement surrounding the release of her solo film effectively marked Scarlett Johansson's departure from the role.