No, it is generally not recommended to talk to Emhyr during the "Brothers In Arms: Nilfgaard" quest.
Why Interacting with Emhyr Is Not Advised
When considering whether to approach Emhyr for assistance in your quest, it's crucial to understand the implications of such an encounter. The outcome of meeting with him is consistently negative and does not provide any beneficial support for Geralt's objectives.
Here are the key reasons why speaking to Emhyr is best avoided:
- No Tangible Help is Gained: Despite the potential hope for imperial aid, meeting with Emhyr ultimately yields no actual assistance for your cause. He will not commit his forces or resources in a way that directly benefits Geralt's mission.
- Insurmountable Leadership Disagreement: Emhyr will insist that any Nilfgaardian forces lent to your aid must be commanded by General Voorhis. This condition is fundamentally unacceptable to Geralt, creating an immediate and irreconcilable conflict. There is no way to persuade Emhyr to change his stance on this matter.
- Abrupt and Disappointing Quest Conclusion: The encounter with Emhyr will automatically bring the "Brothers In Arms: Nilfgaard" quest to an end. This conclusion is described as disappointing because it results in a failure to secure any necessary help and leaves the objective unfulfilled. There is no strategic advantage to initiating an encounter that concludes the quest on such a negative note.
In summary, pursuing a conversation with Emhyr will not advance your efforts and only leads to a futile and dissatisfying conclusion to this part of the "Brothers in Arms" questline. It's more efficient to focus on other avenues for assistance.
